I settled on Blog2Print, and ordered the first four years, 2007 - 2010.
There are options for the type of cover and the picture for the cover page.
There are also options for the layout of the pictures and text. The quality of the print and the color of the photos are very good.
You can also select photos for the back covers.
I also used Blogger's utility to export all the posts from my blog to a backup on my computer, which could be used to restore my blog if it was lost for any reason.